Animated GIFs

From Anarchy In Action

GIFs are making a *big* comeback, thanks to the popularity of sites like tumblr, reddit, and imgur. And here I thought the Geocities style was behind us and I'd never have to make a GIF animation for the Web again... someday, I want to post my "Animated GIF Parade" circa 1999 on, but I'm unsure about the copyright status. Anyway, here's an edited version of a GIF tutorial for making smooth-looking GIFs. ~ Diggity (talk) 12:35, 18 March 2014 (EDT)

Note: The PNG format was created to replace GIFs, and you should use it for non-animated images (esp. those requiring transparency) that are not photos. Use JPEG for photo-realistic images. The GIF file format was patent-encumbered, but can now be used freely.

Getting Started

Making high-quality GIFs with GIMP

Adapted from SarcasticUserName's post on imgur.

GIF Quality

Many image boards and community sites will show a GIF preview, and then allow you to "zoom" by clicking or mousing over the image. A recommended minimum image width for high-quality, "zoomable" GIFs is 611px and a recommended maximum is 1280px. Keeping the image width near ~600px gives you a starting point, so that you can then try to stay under upload caps on specific websites (e.g. 5MB limit on upload filesize). This wiki has a 7MB limit.

Filesize increases not only with the image quality, but how the image was compressed and, in the case of animation, the number and quality of each frame. Animation frames in the GIF will show up as Layers in GIMP.

One tip for reducing filesize would be to reduce the canvas size to include only the important part of the gif instead of scaling down the image. Try to crop the image to fit only the portion of the GIF you need to show, but keep the overall size at 611px (or thereabouts).

Standard GIF made with GIMP

Standard gif.gif

This animation was created by loading individuals frames captured from a video as different layers in GIMP

I deleted the layers I didn't need to get the looping effect and exported it as a GIF choosing the As Animation and Loop Forever options.

Because this image only has 6 layers it is only about 3MB while still having very large dimensions (1280x720). As you can see in the image, the conversion to the .gif file format caused an overall loss in quality particularly on the bunny. Areas throughout the image show wavy lines and smudged areas.

  • A GIF image is limited to 256 colors, so when you take an still image such as .jpg, .png, .bmp and convert them to .gif there's going to be a quality loss. To reduce the impact of this we can do what's called dithering in the indexed color mode.

GIF with Indexed Colors, "web-optimized palette", color dithering

Indexed gif.gif

For this image, I chose Image -> Mode -> Indexed from the GIMP menu and the "Use web-optimized palette" option while selecting the dithering options below. The image is grainy throughout, but you don't have the wide wavy lines and smudged-looking areas that you see in the first image.

  • Color dithering: Floyd-Steinberg (normal)
  • Enable dithering of transparency: checked

GIF with Indexed Colors, "Generate optimum palette", color dithering

Dithering gif.gif

Since the web-optimized palette didn't look great, let's try other GIMP options. Under Indexed Color Conversion, choose "Generate optimum palette", and set the maximum number of colors to 256. Keep the dithering the same; in most cases you will not notice a difference between the dithering modes "Floyd-Steinberg (normal)" and "Floyd-Steinberg (reduced color bleeding)". But feel free to test these different options.

While still a little grainy, especially when zoomed in, the image quality does appear to be much higher and the textures seem smoother. At least in this case, "Generate optimum palette" had the best results, but YMMV.

More Resources

Bashful gif.gif